The Pros and Cons of Marble Countertops: An Interior Designer’s Honest Take

If you’ve ever been deep in the kitchen or bathroom remodeling zone, chances are marble countertops have popped up on your mood board. Whether it’s Carrara, Calacatta Viola, or Arabescato, we get why marble is so irresistible. At Audrey Scheck Design, we’ve definitely fallen hard for marble more than once, and today, we’re sharing an honest breakdown of the pros and cons of marble countertops to help you decide if they’re the right choice for your home.

Why Marble Countertops Are So Popular

Let’s start with the obvious: marble is beautiful. Each slab is unique, formed by nature over millions of years, with gorgeous veining that no engineered material can replicate. Marble brings a quiet, timeless luxury to any space. Whether your style is clean and modern, layered and traditional, or somewhere in between, marble countertops tend to complement a wide range of kitchen and bathroom designs.

The History and Soul Behind Marble Countertops

Marble isn’t just a pretty surface, it has a story. From Parisian architecture to Renaissance sculptures and centuries-old cathedrals, marble has been a symbol of elegance and craftsmanship for ages. Choosing marble countertops means inviting a bit of history and artistry into your home. That said, it’s not a “set it and forget it” material, you’ll want to be prepared for some care and maintenance.

Marble Countertops Pros and Cons: How Marble Ages Over Time

One of marble’s most distinctive qualities is that it changes with use. Marble develops a patina - subtle etches, soft stains, and gentle wear that tells the story of your home. If you love the charm of a worn leather jacket or your favorite pair of broken-in jeans, this natural aging might feel romantic and unique to you. However, if you prefer your countertops to look exactly as pristine as the day they were installed, marble might not be your perfect match.

Marble Countertop Maintenance: What You Need to Know

Marble is porous and softer than many other countertop materials, so it requires regular care:

• Sealing: Marble should be sealed every 6–12 months to protect against stains.

• Spills: Acidic substances like citrus juice, vinegar, and wine can etch or stain marble, so wiping spills promptly is key.

• Daily Use: In bathrooms, marble is usually less demanding. In kitchens, it’s best for those willing to be mindful but not obsessive about upkeep.

If you’re okay with a little lived-in character and willing to keep an eye on spills, marble can be a gorgeous, rewarding choice.

Marble Countertop Cost: Is Marble Worth the Investment?

Marble countertops tend to be a splurge compared to other materials. Carrara marble is often more affordable, while varieties like Calacatta can come with a higher price tag. However, marble can add real value, especially when used thoughtfully. Many designers recommend incorporating marble strategically, such as on a kitchen island or a bathroom vanity, to balance impact with budget and maintenance.

Carrara vs. Calacatta Marble: Which Should You Choose?

• Carrara Marble: Features softer, more subtle veining, typically available at a lower price point. It’s a great choice if you want marble’s beauty without the highest cost.

• Calacatta Marble: Known for bold, dramatic veining and a bright white background, Calacatta is usually more luxurious and pricier.

Both options bring elegance, but your choice depends on your style preference and budget.

Is Marble Right for Your Kitchen or Bathroom?

At the end of the day, marble countertops are not for everyone and that’s perfectly okay. If you appreciate a surface that tells a story, ages gracefully, and embraces imperfection, marble might be your soulmate. If you prefer ultra-low-maintenance, flawless countertops, there are many beautiful alternatives like quartz, granite, or engineered stone that could be a better fit for your lifestyle.

Frequently Asked Questions About Marble Countertops

Is marble too high-maintenance for kitchen countertops? 

Marble does require care like regular sealing and prompt spill cleanup, but with a bit of mindfulness, it can be a stunning and functional choice.

Can you mix marble with other countertop materials? 

Absolutely! Many homeowners use marble on an island or vanity paired with more durable materials elsewhere to balance beauty and practicality.

How long do marble countertops last? 

With proper care, marble countertops can last decades, developing a unique patina that adds to their charm.

Ready to Bring Marble into Your Home?

Still not sure if marble countertops are the right fit? We’re here to help! Whether you want to explore different natural stone options or need guidance choosing the perfect slab, let’s chat.

Based in Austin, Texas, we work with clients nationwide to create homes that feel beautiful, functional, and uniquely their own. Whether it’s a full remodel or just refreshing one room, let’s design a space that truly reflects your lifestyle.

Contact us here to get started!

All Photos by Cate Black